Gold vs Sensex: Which Gave Better Returns in the Last 10 Years?

Gold and the Sensex have given similar nominal CAGR (around 11-12%) over the last 10 years, but the Sensex is more volatile in the short term, while gold acts as a portfolio stabiliser during economic stress. Most financial planners advise holding both in a diversified portfolio rather than choosing one over the other.

In India, people who want to make money over the long term can put their money into metals, mutual funds, stocks, fixed deposits, and other things. Each has a different amount of risk and reward. Among these, gold and the Sensex remain the two most widely tracked benchmarks for everyday Indian investors. Both carry a fair bit of risk, and both have historically delivered inflation-beating returns over time.

If you're trying to decide how to split your money between gold and the stock market, this comparison looks at ten years of real data, including returns, drawdowns, CAGR, and how each asset has actually behaved during different market cycles.

These figures are based on BSE Sensex index levels and IBJA/24K gold price data (per 10 grams). They both have about the same long-term CAGR, but they get there in very different ways. The Sensex goes up and down more quickly and in smaller windows of time, while gold moves steadily over long periods of time with the occasional sharp spike.

Over the last ten years, the table below shows the annual returns for gold (shown as 24K per 10 grammes) and the Sensex (shown as the BSE index). The gold numbers come from the average annual price of 24K gold in India. The Sensex numbers come from the end of the financial year for the index

Gold returns reflect calendar-year average 24K prices per 10 grams; Sensex returns reflect financial-year (April-March) index performance. The two timeframes are offset by a few months, which is standard practice when comparing an internationally-priced commodity with a financial-year-tracked equity index.

• Gold outperformed during global stress years: 2019-20 (the COVID-19 build-up) and 2022-23 (the global rate-hike cycle and geopolitical uncertainty following the Russia-Ukraine conflict) were both periods where gold significantly outpaced the Sensex.
• The Sensex gave better returns in domestic growth phases: FY2020-21 (post-COVID recovery rally) & FY2023-24 (a year of strong domestic consumption and FII inflows) saw the Sensex generate returns well above gold’s.
• Neither asset wins every year: In the ten years that were compared, gold did better four times, and the Sensex did better six times. This data shows that past success by one asset doesn't always mean that it will be the winner the next year.
• 2023-24 was a close shave: Gold (+23.1%) and the Sensex (+24.9%) both delivered healthy double-digit gains in the same year, proving that the two assets don’t always go in opposite directions.

These are the reasons why holding both gold and stocks can help a portfolio do better overall. They react to different, and sometimes opposite, economic signals.

Gold tends to rise when inflation runs high, global geopolitical tension increases safe-haven demand, the rupee weakens against the dollar (since gold is priced in dollars internationally), or real interest rates fall (making non-yielding assets like gold relatively more attractive).

The Sensex is likely to do well when GDP growth is good, corporate earnings are rising, there is positive FII inflow and interest rates are either falling or steady (which supports equity valuation).

The COVID-19 pandemic saw the average price of 24K gold in India rise from approximately ₹35,220 per 10 grams in 2019 to nearly ₹48,651 in 2020 – an increase of about 38% in just one year, as investors sought safety amid unprecedented economic uncertainty. Gold has seen a revival amid the global rate-hike cycle of 2022-23 as central banks worldwide have lifted rates to fight inflation, with investors hedging against currency and inflation risk. More recently, continued geopolitical uncertainty through 2024-25 has kept gold prices on a strong upward trend, with central bank gold purchases providing further support to global demand.

Markets delivered a stellar 69.2% return in FY2020-21, rebounding sharply from the COVID-19 crash on fiscal stimulus, vaccine rollouts and return of corporate earnings growth. FY2023-24 saw another strong run with Sensex up nearly 25% on the back of strong domestic consumption, infrastructure spending and record FII inflows into Indian equities. Over the full 10-year period, the Sensex has delivered a CAGR of roughly 10.8% — broadly in line with gold but arrived at through sharper short-term swings rather than gold's steadier climb.

Nominal returns tell you how much your investment grew in rupee terms. Real returns tell you how much it actually grew after accounting for the rising cost of living — and that's the number that matters for long-term wealth creation.

India's average retail (CPI) inflation over the last decade has hovered broadly in the 5-5.5% range, based on data from the Reserve Bank of India and the Ministry of Statistics. Using that benchmark, here's how nominal returns translate into real purchasing power gained:

In simple terms: if gold delivered a 13% nominal CAGR while inflation averaged around 5.3% a year, your real purchasing power grew by roughly 7.7% annually — meaningfully more than the headline number suggests, but also meaningfully less than the sticker figure implies if you only look at nominal growth. The same adjustment applies to equity returns. This is one of the most overlooked aspects of any gold-vs-equity comparison, since most articles quote nominal figures without accounting for what inflation quietly takes back.

Returns only tell half the story — the path an investment takes to get there matters just as much, especially if you might need to exit at an inconvenient time.

One layer of risk unique to gold for Indian investors is currency exposure. Since gold is priced internationally in US dollars, a weakening rupee can amplify gold's returns in INR terms, while a strengthening rupee can dampen them — even when the global dollar price of gold hasn't moved much. This currency effect partly explains why gold's INR returns in India don't always track its dollar-denominated global price one-for-one.

Common misconception: It is a common belief among investors that gold and the Sensex are always inversely correlated – when gold goes up, stocks go down and vice versa. But data does not support this as a hard and fast rule. In 2023-24, both assets moved strongly together, with gold up 23.1% and Sensex up 24.9% in the same period. There are other periods when both have also moved down together, especially during sudden crunches in liquidity like the initial days of the March 2020 crash, when even gold dipped briefly as investors sold everything to raise cash. The negative correlation between gold and equities is a tendency over certain market conditions, not a guaranteed inverse relationship.

There is no one correct answer to gold versus the Sensex – the right mix depends on your risk appetite, time horizon and what role you want each asset to play.

• Conservative investors, who want to protect their money and guard against inflation, might put around 15 to 20 per cent of their portfolio in gold and use it as a stabiliser rather than a main growth driver.
• Balanced investors looking for moderate growth and some downside protection tend to diversify more evenly with stocks being employed for wealth creation over time and gold being used as a hedge against stress in the market.
• Stocks might be more attractive to the growth-oriented investor with a minimum of a seven-year time horizon. The stock market has rewarded those who are patient and can accept short-term setbacks for better long-term growth.

Most financial planners recommend a blended portfolio rather than an all-or-nothing approach between the two asset classes, since gold and equity tend to respond differently to economic cycles, smoothing out overall portfolio returns over time.

You don't need to buy physical gold or individual stocks for this exposure - gold ETFs and gold mutual funds give you a paper-gold route with no worries about storage or purity, and equity mutual funds let you be a part of Sensex-level growth without picking individual stocks. You can explore and compare these options or estimate potential returns on the ABCD app.

Start your equity investment journey with Aditya Birla Sun Life Mutual Funds. Calculate Now.